Mullet aren't that great!

This forum is for general discussion related to Angling. Areas covered would include Media Reports, Conservation Issues and the promotion of the sport.

Moderators: jd, kieran, Tanglerat, teacher

Message
Author
User avatar
fishinmidget
Casting Tart
Posts: 1829
Joined: Tue May 09, 2006 9:23 pm
Favourite Rod: Daiwa TDXS 129pm
Favourite Reel: Daiwa 7ht Turbo
Favourite Fish: Anything
Location: Was Galway, but sadly now its landlocked London
Has thanked: 4 times
Been thanked: 24 times

Mullet aren't that great!

#1 Post by fishinmidget »

A little bit of a rant here lads.

Recently on the forum, it seems that Mullet are becoming more and more popular. This isn't really any big deal, but it does seem to encorage certain ideas about them that aren't very accurate in my view.

Number one, the idea that mullet are hard to catch. This is total crap. Just like any other fish, they have times when they feed and times when they don't feed. The whole idea that mullet are hard to catch is purely from people fishing at the wrong time, in the wrong place with the wrong bait. Bread is a good bait for mullet, but only if they are used to it. After all, you wouldn't try to catch a fish that fed exclusively on shrimp with a head of mackerel would you? Just as fly anglers say, you have to 'match the hatch'. When you get the time, place and bait right, they are almost stupidly easy to get.

Number two, the idea that mullet are hard fighters. This isn't that untrue, lots of mullet do fight very well indeed. But a large number of the fish i have caught(more than half) have been sort of lazy, head shaking, dead weight on the end of the line kind of fish. Not the sort of thing that gets your heart racing.

Only two points there, but i feel they are the two most common misconceptions.

Don't get me wrong, mullet are addictive. Much like bass, you get hooked(pardon the pun) on catching them. But i think that there is this air of mystique about them that they don't really deserve. No doubt people will disagree with me, but so what, i am safe in the knowledge that i have probably caught more mullet than you anyway.

Rant over

Alex
SACN number: 0688

Le rosbif......
captain AHAB
SAI Hammerhead
Posts: 208
Joined: Sat May 31, 2008 3:39 am
Location: BALDOYLE,DUBLIN

Re: Mullet aren't that great!

#2 Post by captain AHAB »

fishinmidget wrote:A little bit of a rant here lads.

Recently on the forum, it seems that Mullet are becoming more and more popular. This isn't really any big deal, but it does seem to encorage certain ideas about them that aren't very accurate in my view.

Number one, the idea that mullet are hard to catch. This is total crap. Just like any other fish, they have times when they feed and times when they don't feed. The whole idea that mullet are hard to catch is purely from people fishing at the wrong time, in the wrong place with the wrong bait. Bread is a good bait for mullet, but only if they are used to it. After all, you wouldn't try to catch a fish that fed exclusively on shrimp with a head of mackerel would you? Just as fly anglers say, you have to 'match the hatch'. When you get the time, place and bait right, they are almost stupidly easy to get.

Number two, the idea that mullet are hard fighters. This isn't that untrue, lots of mullet do fight very well indeed. But a large number of the fish i have caught(more than half) have been sort of lazy, head shaking, dead weight on the end of the line kind of fish. Not the sort of thing that gets your heart racing.

Only two points there, but i feel they are the two most common misconceptions.

Don't get me wrong, mullet are addictive. Much like Bass, you get hooked(pardon the pun) on catching them. But i think that there is this air of mystique about them that they don't really deserve. No doubt people will disagree with me, but so what, i am safe in the knowledge that i have probably caught more mullet than you anyway.

Rant over

Alex
hi man,i doubt you have more mullet than alot of guys on here but any way i have to say that your talking complete rubbish.

firstly mullet are quite hard to catch due to their feeding habits,small mouth and nervous disposition.
even though they may enter a flooding harbour to feed on offal they can be turned onto bread with some patience.

secondly mullet are very hard fighters on the right gear,(maybe you use a 30-50lb boat rod and 7000 reel??)but as they get larger say over 5lb or so they can seem lazy much the same as bass and seatrout but i think this is due to them taking in too much water whilst being retrieved with their mouth open .

anyway, i think you just want to start a row for the crack.....either that or your just brain farting. :roll:
dbrock
SAI Megalodon!
Posts: 2177
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 10:16 am
Favourite Rod: Zziplex m4 gt
Favourite Reel: Daiwa 7ht mag
Favourite Fish: Tope/ Smoothounds
Location: dub/wick
Has thanked: 38 times
Been thanked: 44 times

Re: Mullet aren't that great!

#3 Post by dbrock »

i have found them hard to catch, and have never got one yet,
fintasticaquatics
http://www.ecrsac.com
EAST COAST RAIDERS MEMBER 2011
[color=#BF0000]SPORTSCAST IRELAND 2011[/color]
User avatar
husshunter
SAI Bait Ball
Posts: 192
Joined: Sun Nov 22, 2009 11:22 pm
Favourite Rod: zippy dream machine
Favourite Reel: 65mag
Favourite Fish: bass
Location: galway
Been thanked: 2 times

Re: Mullet aren't that great!

#4 Post by husshunter »

have to agree with alex here i first started fly fishing for mullet about 16 or 17 years ago and caught plenty and still do any time i want, as for hard fighters i like to use light tackle 4 weight fly rod 4lbs line so any fish over a pound is going to give a scrap .Has anyone caught a salmon on 4 lbs line i can tell you they give a much better scrap than any mullet much more endurance than an over weight over hyped fish.My brother caught 11 one night in bad conditions loads of wind no fish to be seen on the surface and he used a nymph 11 MULLET 2 HOURS FISHING NOT A HARD FISH TO CATCH.
User avatar
Tanglerat
Moderator
Posts: 3117
Joined: Wed Jun 02, 2004 12:45 am
Location: Co Donegal
Has thanked: 43 times
Been thanked: 314 times

Re: Mullet aren't that great!

#5 Post by Tanglerat »

Captain, I doubt if many posters on SAI have caught as many mullet as the little rosbiff. Not saying he's the guy who's caught the most or is the best at it, but he's one of the posters on here that I'd listen to carefully for tips and hints when mullet are being caught.

Aex, I reckon it's a good thing mullet are getting this reputation. I'd love to see them as popular and fished for as much as Bass. So popular in fact that they get the same degree of protection as Bass.

The comparason to Bass fishing is excellent. You find on here anglers desperate to catch one and others that are over the moon that they've finaly caught one. Yet you also have anglers who can catch them seemingly on a whim. Ask them their secrets and they'll tell you it's all about understanding the fish, it's environment, habits and habitat. It's the range of influences that dictate whether fish are there or not, are feeding or not or can be induced into taking a hook or not.

And that's the joy of angling, be it whatever fish you target. Not the scrap, as fun as that is. It's about mastering the skills and watercraft.
User avatar
red
SAI Megalodon!
Posts: 1666
Joined: Tue Oct 14, 2008 4:30 pm
Location: cork
Has thanked: 154 times
Been thanked: 176 times

Re: Mullet aren't that great!

#6 Post by red »

i got my 1st one yesterday. was targeting something else without sucess. there was loads of mullet around and i decided to have a half arsed crack at them. i had 20lb braid on, attached to 10lb fluro, attached to 6lb mono :roll: . i had tiny fresh water hooks on baited with 2 peeled crab legs on a 15-50g lure rod.
was gettin nothin when bang. something went off like stink. after a few spirited little runs i got it in. he was less than a lb i'd say but a good little scrapper all the same.
was it hard to catch?? dunno. there was hundreds of them around and all i got was 1, but like i said. it really was a half arsed attempt at them.
did it fight hard? for a fish so small it did and cant comment on the bigger ones, but ive have more fun with the smaller bass of 2-4lbs than bass of 5-8lbs
User avatar
johnfish
SAI Bait Ball
Posts: 133
Joined: Sun Aug 02, 2009 5:47 pm

Re: Mullet aren't that great!

#7 Post by johnfish »

mullet can be difficult to catch ,they also can be easy same as every fish,(once caught 12 salmon in 2 hours,28 bass in the same time frame)they give a great scrap using the right tackle ,i also have caught a lot of mullet.and so what if there getting popular to fish for,by the way they tend to be handy caught in galway because there getting fed bread every day by the tourists feeding the ducks and seagulls,kinda like fishing for goldfish in a garden pond.strangest thing i ever saw going on a fishing forum to slag fish ,feck it think ill just fish for blue fin from now on bass and salmon too easy to catch and they fight terrible lmao
User avatar
saltydog
SAI Megalodon!
Posts: 1816
Joined: Tue May 15, 2007 8:52 pm
Location: Galway / Wexford
Has thanked: 26 times
Been thanked: 20 times

Re: Mullet aren't that great!

#8 Post by saltydog »

johnfish wrote:by the way they tend to be handy caught in galway because there getting fed bread every day by the tourists feeding the ducks and seagulls,kinda like fishing for goldfish in a garden pond.
Just for the record fishing is not permitted in this area so for anyone reading please don't attempt to do so
Shore Species 2011 (31) Ballan Wrasse, Bass, Bullhuss, Coalfish, Cod, Conger, Corkwing Wrasse, Cuckoo Ray, Dab, Dogfish, Five Bearded Rockling, Flounder, Goldsinny Wrasse, Long Spined Sea Scorpion, Mackerel, Plaice, Pollack, Poor Cod, Pouting, Rock Goby, Shanny, Shore Rockling, Short Spined Sea Scorpion, Thornback Ray, Three Bearded Rockling, Tompot Blenny, Tope, Tub Gurnard, Turbot, Undulate Ray, Whiting

Shore Species 2010 (26) - Bass, Black Goby, Bull Huss, Coalfish, Cod, Dab, Dogfish, Five Bearded Rockling, Flounder, Grey Gurnard, Lesser Weaver, Mackerel, Mullet, Plaice, Pollack, Poor cod, Pouting, Rock Goby, Shore Rockling, Silver eel, Starry Smooth Hound, Thornback Ray, Tope, Tub Gurnard, Turbot, Whiting

[url=http://galwaybuccaneerssac.com]Galway Buccaneers SAC[/url]
Bradan
SAI Megalodon!
Posts: 1077
Joined: Thu Sep 15, 2005 5:32 pm
Location: On a beach/lake/river somewhere..
Has thanked: 70 times
Been thanked: 129 times

Re: Mullet aren't that great!

#9 Post by Bradan »

Tanglerat wrote: the little rosbiff
:lol: :lol: :lol: I love it, that's what I'm calling him from now on!
Its called fishing, not catching. If it was called catching it wouldn't be fishing!

http://www.flickr.com/photos/bradan99
User avatar
fishinmidget
Casting Tart
Posts: 1829
Joined: Tue May 09, 2006 9:23 pm
Favourite Rod: Daiwa TDXS 129pm
Favourite Reel: Daiwa 7ht Turbo
Favourite Fish: Anything
Location: Was Galway, but sadly now its landlocked London
Has thanked: 4 times
Been thanked: 24 times

Re: Mullet aren't that great!

#10 Post by fishinmidget »

Right, so now that i am a little more awake and its not 3am, i see that i might have mis-labeled this thread slightly. The title should have read: Common misconceptions about mullet, or something like that. Oh well, live and learn.
captain AHAB wrote: hi man,i doubt you have more mullet than alot of guys on here but any way i have to say that your talking complete rubbish.

firstly mullet are quite hard to catch due to their feeding habits,small mouth and nervous disposition.
even though they may enter a flooding harbour to feed on offal they can be turned onto bread with some patience.

secondly mullet are very hard fighters on the right gear,(maybe you use a 30-50lb boat rod and 7000 reel??)but as they get larger say over 5lb or so they can seem lazy much the same as Bass and seatrout but i think this is due to them taking in too much water whilst being retrieved with their mouth open .

anyway, i think you just want to start a row for the crack.....either that or your just brain farting. :roll:
Firstly, i want to make it clear that i only want to see the view of others, and to find out if anyone else feels the same way i do. I do not want to start an argument for the sake of it. If you have a better idea of how to find out other peoples views on this subject, tell me.

The whole "more mullet" thing, i don't post reports so i don't expect you to believe that.

Small mouths? Are you kidding? Ok, they may not be cod or bass sized but i can still fit 3 fingers into the mouth of a 5 pounder to get the hook out.

You gave a good example of mullet coming into a harbour to feed on fishy leftovers that have been dumped by boats. As you say, you can turn them onto bread with a bit of patience. My question is, why would you bother? Why not give the fish what they have come to feed on? I have always found that a small piece of mackerel works wonders when there are fishing boats or trawlers present.

I have about 6 different rods that i fish for mullet with, depending on the location and the method. The heaviest of these is a 12' salmon bait fishing rod that i pair with a 5000 sized shimano stradic and 15lb braid. Everything else i have is lighter than that.
Tanglerat wrote: Aex, I reckon it's a good thing mullet are getting this reputation. I'd love to see them as popular and fished for as much as Bass. So popular in fact that they get the same degree of protection as Bass.
Thats a pretty good point, i hadn't thought of that.
johnfish wrote:By the way, they tend to be handy caught in galway because there getting fed bread every day by the tourists feeding the ducks and seagulls, kinda like fishing for goldfish in a garden pond. Strangest thing i ever saw going on a fishing forum to slag fish, feck it think ill just fish for blue fin from now on Bass and salmon too easy to catch and they fight terrible lmao
As Conor said John, fishing isn't allowed in that area. Most of my recent fishing for them has been about 10 miles out from Galway. Did i say they fought terrible? No, i said that some(not all) aren't as good as some people make them out to be. Mullet just so happen to be my favourite fish, and it will most likely stay that way for some time.

Alex
SACN number: 0688

Le rosbif......
lodore
SAI Bait Ball
Posts: 134
Joined: Wed Oct 28, 2009 8:17 pm
Been thanked: 45 times

Re: Mullet aren't that great!

#11 Post by lodore »

fishinmidget wrote: Just like any other fish, they have times when they feed and times when they don't feed. The whole idea that mullet are hard to catch is purely from people fishing at the wrong time, in the wrong place with the wrong bait.
I'm not trying to stir it up, but this statement is true of every fish from a tompot blenny to a great white. I daresay you'd catch plenty of either––and everything in between--if you had all the relevant info on feeding location and timing. What makes a species hard to catch is learning this information and putting it into effect. It may well be that this info is easy to learn for mullet; I don't know as I never fished for or caught one. The fact remains, though, that saying mullet are easy to catch once you know shed-loads about mullet kind of misses the point.

Return to “Angling News, Issues, Comments and Opinions”